He Doesn’t Look Disabled.

How many times have those of us with hearing loss been told that we don’t look deaf, whatever “looking” deaf means. It’s hard enough to make people recognize invisible disabilities. but today’s New York Times has an Op-Ed that suggests it’s okay to question the disabled status even of someone with visible disabilities.

photo of pwd sign
Photo by Ann H on Pexels.com

In “The Truth About Harvey Weinstein’s Walker,” Jasmine E. Harris, a professor at the law school of the University of California, Davis, argues that the “‘aesthetics of disability’ produce visceral responses in jurors and the public that can lead them to be more (or less) sympathetic when weighing a defendant’s liability, public responsibility and, in the end, punishment.”

While not outright accusing Weinstein and his attorneys of manipulating a perception of disability, Ms. Harris does say conclusively that this has been done by others: “Or the truth might be that he, like many others before him, will hope the benefit of disability aesthetics will help him in the courtroom.” (Italics mine.)

Readers quickly picked up on his rumpled clothes and slippers as further proof of his phony disability, but don’t forget that Weinstein seemed to spend much of his time in a bathrobe even in so-called business meetings. (I have zero sympathy for Weinstein, so don’t misconstrue my argument.)

Weinstein may be exaggerating his inability walk unaided, but I’m shocked that a professor of  law would suggest that we doubt someone’s else’s disability. It’s hard enough for those with disabilities to get the aid and services they need — or even a seat on the bus or the subway — without someone with Ms. Harris’s credentials suggesting that it’s okay to question someone’s right to their disability status.

It may be a clever legal strategy, but it undermines the credibility of all people with disabilities. Truthfully, I don’t think this was Ms. Harris’s intention, but it certainly lends itself to the argument that, like the welfare queens of the ’60’s, some people with disabilities just want favored treatment.

For more about living with hearing loss, read my books, available at Amazon.com and maybe at your favorite bookstore or library. If it’s not there, ask for it!

Smart Hearing Cover final

 

shoutingwonthelp