Breaking a Logjam on Over-the-Counter Hearing Aids

Cheaper and More Accessible Hearing Aids Could Also Help Reduce Stigma

This essay originally ran on Bloomberg View, December 12, 2016. HEALTH CARE

In the uncertainty over the future of U.S. health care, there is one ray of hope for a group of people who need more options, not fewer.

People with hearing loss usually pay out of pocket for hearing aids, and those pockets must be deep indeed. The average cost for a hearing aid is $2,300, and most people need two. They don’t last forever, and if your condition is progressive you may need to replace them as often as every four or five years.

No matter what your income level, hearing aids for adults are not covered by health insurance. They are not covered by Medicare, and they are not covered by most state Medicaid programs. The Affordable Care Act does not cover hearing aids. Some private insurers are beginning to pay, but it’s usually only a fraction of the whole. The V.A. and some state vocational bureaus do provide hearing aids. But essentially, you’re on your own.

The good news comes in the form of a bipartisan bill introduced in the Senate by Republican Charles Grassley of Iowa and Democrat Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts.

Their Over-the-Counter Hearing Aid Act of 2016, introduced on Dec. 1, would make certain basic hearing aids available over the counter and at a far cheaper price than what a decent hearing aid costs today. Whether these devices would be called “hearing aids” under Food and Drug Administration regulations remains to be seen, but they will be hearing-aid-like devices made by hearing-aid manufacturers.

These devices are not for people like me with severe to profound loss. But they are what the more than 30 million Americans with age-related hearing loss could use, at least as starter devices. If the loss progresses, the need for more sophisticated equipment increases.

The Academy of Doctors of Audiology supports the bill with the caveat that the over-the-counter products “be very specifically labelled and include a strong recommendation that a patient seek a comprehensive audiological evaluation from an audiologist or physician.” There are certain red-flag conditions for which a person should always seek medical aid: sudden hearing loss, single-sided or asymmetric hearing loss, drainage from the ear, pain, dizziness.

But, the academy concluded, “There is a preponderance of data available today which demonstrates that when it comes to hearing loss, the risk of non-treatment may be greater than the risk of self-treatment.”

The Hearing Industries Association, while supporting “efforts to increase the accessibility and affordability of hearing aids,” expressed concern about the self-diagnosis of hearing loss. “The Over-the-Counter Hearing Aid Act of 2016 would compel the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to allow OTC hearing aids. This will require consumers to self-diagnose both the cause and degree of their hearing loss…. It would do so in spite of the fact that no studies have indicated that people can accurately self-diagnose either the cause or the extent of their hearing loss.”

A week after Grassley and Warren introduced their bill, the FDA in a surprise announcement indicated that it is considering over-the-counter hearing aids, without any Senate mandate. The FDA announced that, effective immediately, it would no longer require adults to get a medical evaluation (or sign a waiver) before buying most hearing aids. It said that it was also considering creating a new category of OTC hearing aids to encourage “new, innovative, lower-cost products to millions of consumers.”

In doing so, the FDA was following the recommendations of two important scientific groups: the President’s Council on Science and Technology and the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine. Consumer groups like the Hearing Loss Association of America and AARP have already endorsed these recommendations.

Thirty million Americans suffer age-related hearing loss. Only about 14 percent of them currently use hearing aids. The primary reason for this is the high cost.

Barbara Kelley, the executive director of the nonprofit Hearing Loss Association of America, said the group receives requests every day for information about financial assistance for hearing aids. (Disclosure: I am on the HLAA board.) “Sadly, there are few financial aid resources,” Kelley wrote in a letter to the Senate sponsors of the bill.

The high cost contributes to a second reason people don’t use hearing aids: stigma. Most people don’t use them until their hearing has deteriorated substantially, usually as they age. This means that in the popular mind hearing aids are for the elderly — which is false, since more than half of those with hearing loss are under the age of 60. If all the people of all ages who could benefit from hearing aids used them, they would be as common as glasses.

Making hearing aids more affordable and more accessible also increases use. And as use increases, stigma declines. So do the consequences of untreated hearing loss like depression and isolation, cognitive decline and a greater risk of falls. These are enormous public-health issues, as well as personal problems. Reducing the incidence of hearing-related cognitive decline alone will save billions in health-care dollars.

The Grassley-Warren bill is good for people with hearing loss. Even better is that the FDA seems on its way to making the bill unnecessary.

This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.

7 thoughts on “Breaking a Logjam on Over-the-Counter Hearing Aids

  1. That’s wonderful however. I spent over $10,000 for 2 different pair of hearing aids of which neither help. I TO am dead if I do not have my hearing aids on and have just now been exposed to the world of hearing again. Thanks to the aidiologists at COSTCO in Avon Massachusetts. I was spared a cochlear implant. Exhausted if their diligence and Costcos’s superior hearing aids at more affordable prices. I believe they should be fighting for all of us. not just those who can buy over the counter aids.

    Like

    • It would be great if hearing aid prices for all types came down in price. It’s possible that lower prices might lead to insurance coverage for even the higher priced aids. I’m glad you were able to find cheaper aids and a Costco with an audiologist on staff. (I think many Costco’s do have audiologists.)

      Like

  2. Katherine,

    Thank you for sharing this very important information. Hopefully, the FDA will make the Grassley-Warren bill unnecessary. Many people who need hearing aids will benefit from them, bringing down the cost of treating
    the medical, mental health and social problems associated with hearing loss.

    Like

  3. Ms. Bouton,

    Thank you for helping place a spotlight on the issue of hearing loss and the 25 million or so people that do not get the help they need due to the large price tag on hearing aids. I represent General Hearing Instruments, a 30 year old hearing aid manufacturer. Every year we would hold a meeting to discuss result of industry surveys (MarkeTrak), and it became abundantly clear that price was a major hurdle to people getting the help they needed. About 10 years ago we decided that we would take on this challenge of providing hearing aids for up to a moderate hearing loss while keeping the price affordable. Our Simplicity and Simply Soft direct to consumer hearing aids average about $450/ea not $2500 ea as is standard. We back all of our devices with a 90 day, 100% money back guarantee and 1 year warranty.
    In the subsequent years we have assembled a distribution network that includes walmart.com, samsclub.com, staples.com, sears.com, AAFES, and others. It has been a long road, littered with legal challenges from audiologists and audiology groups looking to protect the current system that often times looks to protect the pocket book of the medical professional instead of what is in the best interest of the patient. Fortunately, we have survived all legal challenges. It is great to see this movement take legs and start to grow. I would love to chat with you about our products. Please feel free to email if you would like more info.

    Like

Please leave a reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s